from the edge

Showing posts with label the politics of hope. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the politics of hope. Show all posts

Tuesday, 22 September 2015

Cross purpose

Coventry Cross
aprilyamasaki.com
As you go down the stairs to the café at Coventry Cathedral, you pass the burned cross which was made of two pieces of wood found in the rubble of the bombed out original building. They were found lying together in the position of a cross. The stone mason, Jock Forbes, who was working on the new building, tied them in that position and there they stand behind a glass panel engraved with the words ‘Father forgive’.

If you are a first time visitor to the cathedral, you might not expect to come across a burned cross on the wall as you hurry downstairs for a cup of coffee. You are surprised by it, as if you were being accosted by a stranger. You are unsettled by the encounter even though it proves, after all, not to be violent or in any way threatening, although you find that the disparate thoughts which are swirling around in your head as you hurry down the stairs, are suddenly interrupted, as if they were being held to account, in a way which is profoundly disturbing.

It is as if this fleeting and seemingly inconsequential moment encompasses the whole of history of which you are an integral part. It questions it. The charred cross is a reminder of the horrors of war and of the violence wrought on the earth by every generation, and you are a part of that too. The moment of ‘encounter’ allows you to see this and to know it at the deepest level of your hidden inner self, as you read the words ‘Father forgive’ etched into the glass in front of the cross. Seen against the charred cross, the delicately wrought words disturb and shock.

There is another cross in Coventry Cathedral, a replica of one made of nails, nails which were also found in the ruins of the old building. The original nail cross was given to the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church in Berlin as a sign of repentance for the Allied bombing. There have been, and will continue to be, many crosses. But the words ‘Father forgive’ will always remain the same, wherever they are placed and whenever they are said or thought.

Perhaps they will remain because they are not our words. Most of us, if we are honest about it, are not capable of speaking these words for more than a split second before falling back into a place of unforgiveness, hence the continuation of violence at all levels and in every context of human existence. Violence is the only language we really know and feel confident speaking. It is the language of unforgiveness.

Unforgiveness takes many forms. It is not just a perpetuation of hatred. It is more a matter of not being able to let go of fear, something to which we seem to be perversely, if unconsciously,  addicted. So someone else needs to say the words with us and for us, and keep saying them, until we learn not to be afraid of forgiveness and of what it entails. This is the purpose of the cross. It is also what makes an encounter with it both disturbing and life changing.  


Last week I wrote about the politics of hope and one commentator remarked, rightly, that hope, in politics, can be construed in many different ways, depending on individual or collective interests. I think the hope which comes with the forgiveness of the cross takes us beyond these narrow limitations. I also think that faith is sometimes revealed in the way hope is worked out and that, in this respect, it is acceptable for faith to remain undeclared or hidden.

Faith is not invariably a matter of openly declaring oneself to be of any one religion, because true religion does not need to declare itself at all. So it is not for anyone to judge whether another person has faith, or to judge others on the basis of a priori definitions about any one set of religious beliefs. Faith is about faithfulness to ideals, as well as to beliefs, as my commentator pointed out in relation to Jeremy Corbyn’s long years of faithfulness to his vision for a better society. It is also about trusting in a love that has been encountered from outside the limited boundaries of purely human forgiveness. 

Tuesday, 15 September 2015

Socialist Utopia - Or the Kingdom of Heaven?

The artist Ai Wei Wei, when asked on Channel 4 News (September 14th, 2015) why his art is deemed to be so subversive by the Chinese government, replied that art is dangerous.  “It speaks the truth”, he said, by which he meant the kind of truth which inspires hope and resonates with the deepest longings of the human spirit.

www.theguardian.com
One of the most pernicious effects of self-serving power politics, in any context, is that they whittle away at the concept of hope, making it appear either futile, irrelevant or even ridiculous. Wei Wei’s art is the product of a sacrificial life which has been both sustained and given in a hope which refused to be whittled away through months of solitary confinement in Chinese prisons.

 Hope is often mistaken for a kind of naïve dreaming for a perfect world, a perfect future, but it is quite the opposite of this. Hope is grounded in, and shaped by, the hard knocks of experience. It often pays a heavy price for what it gives of itself, but the product in the end is life because hope, as opposed to wishful thinking, continually defies what is dead and decayed. This is the central message of Ai Wei Wei’s work. It is also the task to which our politicians are called.

Whatever we may think of the re-formed Labour party and of Jeremy Corbyn, its newly elect leader, his meteoric rise from relative obscurity to totemic political significance, is the single most hope-filled event to have occurred in British politics in decades. He will, of course, disappoint, not so much because many of his dreams are unrealisable at the present moment, given the global conflagration which this nation is caught up in, but because he will have great difficulty persuading his own party to grasp the hope he is offering.

The Blairites will have to forgo infighting. They will also have to resist engaging in the kind of pragmatic and publicly pugilistic politics which have made so many people, especially the young, cynical about the whole political process. Corbyn himself will have to guard against old allies, now receiving the reward which they have perhaps been promised, from persuading him to slip back into the seductive ways of ‘old labour’, a utopia which never really existed, even for those whose lives it was supposed to transform.

What then is the hope he is offering? I think it is a new and fresh vision of politics itself, but also a vision which is deeply grounded in what Jesus would have described as the Kingdom of Heaven. The politics of the Kingdom, like all politics, are worked out in the shaping of economic policies. There are some Christians who will blanche at this idea. Corbyn’s proposed policies are perhaps a little too compatible with the Gospel, a little too truthful for comfort. They also sound like the kind of Christian Marxism which has been put forward in the past by such as Thomas J. Hagerty and Ernst Block in the nineteenth and early twentieth century, (to name only two), as well as those of Oscar Romero and others who even today are held in US prisons for their Kingdom orientated political convictions. The Chinese government is not the only one to feel threatened by the kind of truths exposed in the art of Ai Wei Wei.

Other Christians will be wary of a return to the kind of socialism which stifles economic creativity and the passing on of earned assets to one’s children. They would fear the consequences of the kind of heavy handed secularism, and the atheism which is often automatically associated with it, which denies our basic humanity and destroys the life of the spirit.

Jeremy Corbyn ought to be able to speak into these fears. With his natural grace, measured responses to questions both friendly and hostile, and with his steadiness of purpose, he could be a Christ figure for the nation, irrespective of his own religious convictions, or lack of them. But he cannot be this alone, because hope is something that has to be continually replenished from outside, as well as from within. For Christians, it comes with the grace of knowing and being known by God, so that they can become ‘God-sent’ people in whatever circumstances they find themselves. They become bearers of hope – and not simply celebrities, and this is particularly important in the context of politics.

If Jeremy Corbyn is called to be a Christ figure to the nation, he will need the faith and the spiritual energy generated by those who will pray for him. An Eritrean refugee was asked not long ago why he wanted to go to the UK. He replied “because it is Great Britain”. The prayer we need right now does not need to involve words, or any kind of  mindset or formal liturgical setting. It needs to be the embodiment of the hope, directed at God, that Jeremy Corbyn will one day make this nation great again.